Agency Comp No Longer Allowed on MLS

Explore the impact of the NAR's recent settlement on MLS broker fee transparency and its effects on buyers and sellers.
POSTED ON:
April 27, 2024
UPDATED ON:
April 27, 2024
Category:
Financing

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlement regarding the disclosure of broker compensation on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) marks a significant shift in the real estate industry landscape, sparking debates about its potential impact on buyers and sellers alike. The settlement emerged as a response to concerns raised by the Department of Justice (DOJ) regarding potential antitrust violations related to transparency in real estate transactions.

Under the terms of the settlement, the NAR agreed to no longer allow brokers to disclose the commission they offer to buyer's agents on the MLS. This change could have far-reaching implications for both buyers and sellers in the real estate market.

For buyers, the impact of this settlement is twofold. On one hand, the lack of transparency regarding broker compensation could make it more challenging for buyers to understand the full cost of purchasing a property. Without clear information about the commissions being offered to buyer's agents, buyers may find it difficult to assess whether their agent is acting in their best interest or may be influenced by the commission offered on a particular property.

Additionally, the absence of commission information could hinder buyers' ability to negotiate effectively. When buyers are unaware of the compensation being offered to their agent, they may be at a disadvantage during negotiations, potentially leading to less favorable terms or higher overall costs.

On the other hand, proponents of the settlement argue that removing commission information from the MLS could encourage more competition among real estate agents, leading to potentially lower costs for buyers. Without predetermined commission rates influencing agent behavior, buyers may have access to a wider range of properties and pricing options.

But we can not ignore the obvious. The buyers who have low to moderate income will be affected the most. High-income buyers know they need an agent to represent them and can afford it.

For sellers, the impact of the settlement is similarly complex. On one hand, the lack of transparency regarding broker compensation could make it more challenging for sellers to understand the fees associated with selling their property. Without clear information about the commissions being offered to buyer's agents, sellers may struggle to evaluate the overall cost of working with a particular real estate agent or brokerage.

Additionally, the absence of commission information could impact sellers' ability to effectively market their property. In a market where buyers are unaware of the compensation being offered to their agents, sellers may need to rely more heavily on other factors, such as the attractiveness of the property itself or the quality of the listing agent, to attract potential buyers.

However, proponents of the settlement argue that removing commission information from the MLS could empower sellers by giving them more control over their listing agreements. Without predetermined commission rates dictating agent behavior, sellers may have greater flexibility to negotiate terms that align with their specific needs and goals.

Noting that all commissions to agents have always been negotiated upfront and agreed to in advance of listing the property. These changes will confuss a few at first, but we believe the market will find a rithum with the changes and will be compensated for their experience and dedication.

Overall, the National Association of Realtors settlement regarding broker compensation disclosure on the MLS represents a significant shift in the real estate industry. While the full impact of this change remains to be seen, it is clear that both buyers and sellers will need to adapt to a new landscape characterized by increased complexity and uncertainty.

other blog posts
send us your questions

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlement regarding the disclosure of broker compensation on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) marks a significant shift in the real estate industry landscape, sparking debates about its potential impact on buyers and sellers alike. The settlement emerged as a response to concerns raised by the Department of Justice (DOJ) regarding potential antitrust violations related to transparency in real estate transactions.

Under the terms of the settlement, the NAR agreed to no longer allow brokers to disclose the commission they offer to buyer's agents on the MLS. This change could have far-reaching implications for both buyers and sellers in the real estate market.

For buyers, the impact of this settlement is twofold. On one hand, the lack of transparency regarding broker compensation could make it more challenging for buyers to understand the full cost of purchasing a property. Without clear information about the commissions being offered to buyer's agents, buyers may find it difficult to assess whether their agent is acting in their best interest or may be influenced by the commission offered on a particular property.

Additionally, the absence of commission information could hinder buyers' ability to negotiate effectively. When buyers are unaware of the compensation being offered to their agent, they may be at a disadvantage during negotiations, potentially leading to less favorable terms or higher overall costs.

On the other hand, proponents of the settlement argue that removing commission information from the MLS could encourage more competition among real estate agents, leading to potentially lower costs for buyers. Without predetermined commission rates influencing agent behavior, buyers may have access to a wider range of properties and pricing options.

But we can not ignore the obvious. The buyers who have low to moderate income will be affected the most. High-income buyers know they need an agent to represent them and can afford it.

For sellers, the impact of the settlement is similarly complex. On one hand, the lack of transparency regarding broker compensation could make it more challenging for sellers to understand the fees associated with selling their property. Without clear information about the commissions being offered to buyer's agents, sellers may struggle to evaluate the overall cost of working with a particular real estate agent or brokerage.

Additionally, the absence of commission information could impact sellers' ability to effectively market their property. In a market where buyers are unaware of the compensation being offered to their agents, sellers may need to rely more heavily on other factors, such as the attractiveness of the property itself or the quality of the listing agent, to attract potential buyers.

However, proponents of the settlement argue that removing commission information from the MLS could empower sellers by giving them more control over their listing agreements. Without predetermined commission rates dictating agent behavior, sellers may have greater flexibility to negotiate terms that align with their specific needs and goals.

Noting that all commissions to agents have always been negotiated upfront and agreed to in advance of listing the property. These changes will confuss a few at first, but we believe the market will find a rithum with the changes and will be compensated for their experience and dedication.

Overall, the National Association of Realtors settlement regarding broker compensation disclosure on the MLS represents a significant shift in the real estate industry. While the full impact of this change remains to be seen, it is clear that both buyers and sellers will need to adapt to a new landscape characterized by increased complexity and uncertainty.

download our free guides!

With 20+ years of experience, we created these to help all those who are looking to buy, get financing, and/or sell their homes. These are free and ready to download at the click of a button! Choose a packet to get yours today.

Got a real estate/mortgage question? 
contact us

14 N 5th St
Redlands, CA 92373
(909) 376-8399

Facebook icon to lead to ARRealty Facebook pageFacebook icon to lead to ARRealty Facebook pageYouTube icon to lead to ARRealty YouTube Channel